Why did Khodorkovsky "let his sins" Putin?

19 April 2017, 21:11 | Peace 
фото с Обозреватель

Another text by Mikhail Khodorkovsky "The main terrorist - the system corruption of power" causes another bewilderment.

To begin with, the author "lets go of sins". Putin, - they say, he, Khodorkovsky, "never accused Putin personally of organizing the murders of our citizens". Like, Putin, whom he, Khodorkovsky, "knew", supposedly "was not capable of this".

On the one hand, no one seems to have asked Khodorkovsky for such absolution of sins to Putin,. On the other hand, the presence or absence of such indulgences - even though from Khodorkovsky, from anyone else - is not able to change the firmly entrenched in Russia and the world view on whose orders and in whose interests such operations as "the second Chechen war, "" Ryazan sugar, "" polonium poisoning, "" compelling Georgia for peace, "" annexation of the Crimea, "" Russian peace, "" the war for Novorossia, "" bombing of Syria, "leading to the murder of dozens and hundreds of thousands of citizens - and "our" and "not ours".

If Chechens, Georgians, Ukrainians, Syrians, as well as Russian military and Russian civilians who perished in the endless adventures of Putin's regime for Khodorkovsky, are not "ours" if the residents of the blown up houses on Kashirskoye highway, Guryanov Street in Volgodonsk, , If Yuri Shchekochikhin, Anna Politkovskaya, Alexander Litvinenko, Sergei Magnitsky, Boris Nemtsov - alien to him, then it is completely unimportant whether he considers "his citizens", for example, Vasily Aleksanyan or Alexander Perepelichny.

By releasing his sins personally to Putin, Khodorkovsky nevertheless imposes political responsibility on him. For what? For the fact that he "gave such power to corrupt clans in his entourage, that in their struggle for a sweet piece and influence they are quite capable, if not to organize, then to close their eyes, to push the organization of this terror. Push and pave the way for terrorists, reorienting those to whom citizens pay for their safety, to fight those who prevent these clans from stealing! ".

Stop! Let's figure out what Khodorkovsky is talking about.

According to him, Putin gave the government (obviously, still not corrupt) to corrupt clans in their environment who are capable of:.

A) organize terror, b) turn a blind eye to terror, c) push the organization of terror, push and pave the way for terrorists.

If we do not touch on the minor point two, "close our eyes," Khodorkovsky claims that certain clans surrounded by Putin are capable of:.

A) organization of terror;.

B) assistance in the organization of terror, paving the way for terrorists, that is, in fact, the same thing that he points out in point (a) - the organization of terror.

And here Khodorkovsky should have been more detailed.

If he knows so much about "the organization of terror by corrupt clans surrounded by Putin," then he must openly tell Russian society what he knows about this subject.

First, which clans in Putin's entourage does he have in mind?.

Who goes there? Names? The appearance?.

What kind of clans did Putin give the authorities so that they could "organize terror", "push the organization of terror", "pave the way for terrorists"?.

Khodorkovsky has in mind the corrupt clan D. Medvedev?.

Or I. Sechin?.

Or F. Timchenko?.

Or Rotenberg brothers?.

Or brothers Kovalchuk?.

Or with. Chemezova - With. Ivanova?.

Or in. Zolotova - R. Kadyrov?.

Or someone else?.

Or are they all together?.

Is it precisely they who organize terror?.

Are they paving the way for terrorists?.

Do they close their eyes to (their) terror?.

Secondly, if these (or other, or all) clans in Putin's entourage, according to Khodorkovsky, turned out to be corrupt ("corrupt" - so in the original), and even capable of organizing terror and "paving the way for terrorists," then, Is asked, and who is personally guilty of creating this system of organized terror? And it is for the creation of this system that Khodorkovsky lets go of Putin's sins?.

Thirdly, Khodorkovsky emphasizes the distinction between "corrupt clans surrounded by Putin" and "those to whom citizens pay for their safety". That is, unlike the "corrupt clans in Putin's entourage" Khodorkovsky considers non-corrupt "those to whom citizens pay for their safety", t. Special services and t. Law enforcement agencies? This, of course, is a bold statement, but Khodorkovsky, of course, has the right to it. But then, if the corrupt clans succeed, according to Khodorkovsky, to reorient the special services and law enforcement agencies to fight "those who prevent these clans from stealing," then these special services and these protective bodies are also corrupt? And what then is the fundamental difference between "corrupt clans in Putin's entourage" from those corrupt law enforcement agencies, "to whom do citizens pay for their safety"?.

Fourth, if Khodorkovsky knows that corrupt clans surrounded by Putin's ability to organize terror, and "those who are citizens pay for their own safety", have "reoriented" to fight "those who interfere with corrupt officials to steal," that is, by ordinary citizens, then his appeal to ordinary citizens take to the streets of our cities becomes his appeal to the citizens to become potential victims of terror on the part of "corrupt clans are able to organize terror," and from "those who are paying for the citizens of St. th security ', but who have "reoriented" to their suppression. Very "wise" call.

Finally, if, according to Khodorkovsky, the system of the current Russian government is formed, firstly, clans capable of organizing terror, and secondly, special services and law enforcement bodies reoriented to force suppression of citizens, so, the main problem of present-day Russia stands out Not "systemic corruption of power," but a system of organized violence, repression and terror that protects authoritarian power and systemic corruption.

But against this major Russian problem - the system of organized violence and terror, Khodorkovsky not only does not call for fighting.

He does not even call her.

He is only trying to "reorient" citizens to actions incapable of leading to the achievement of the secondary goal that he has announced, but capable of turning them into victims of a system of organized violence and terror, for the creation of which he has already released Putin's sins.

Editorial site is not responsible for the content of blogs. The editorial opinion may differ from the author's.

Join the groups "Browser Blogs" on Facebook and VKontakte, stay tuned!.

По материалам: aillarionov.livejournal.com